Oxo Vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder : Which Is Better?

Today we are looking at two paper towel holders. The other common name some people may use is paper towel dispensers. Let us explore the Oxo paper towel holder and the Simplehuman paper towel holder. They share quite a number of similar features. For example, they are mainly made out of brushed stainless steel. They also have a free standing design. They do have different features that separate them. They do not cost the same but their price points are not far apart. Regardless, the Oxo and the Simplehuman paper towel holders are both good picks. A detailed look at the two will help you see which is best, the Oxo paper towel holder or the Simplehuman paper towel holder?

Table of Contents

Oxo Vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder: Comparison Table

Oxo Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Material Stainless steel Stainless steel
Mounting type Floor mount Tension Mount
Weight 1.2 pounds 2.2 pounds
Dimensions 7×7×13 inches 7.5×8.25×14.25 inches
Warranty None 5 years
Capacity One roll One roll
Price Check Price On Amazon Check Price On Amazon
Oxo Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Oxo Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder

Oxo Vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder: Design

The Oxo paper towel holder features a free standing design. The Oxo paper towel holder has a spring activated arm; it locks open for loading. The Oxo paper towel holder has a weighted and non-slip base. Overall, the Oxo paper towel holder has a brushed stainless steel design. This contributes to an aesthetic look wherever you place it. The Oxo paper towel holder has a carry knob. The Simplehuman paper towel holder also features a free standing design.

The Simplehuman paper towel holder has a variable tension arm. That arm has internal resistance that allows tearing off just one sheet at a time with just one hand. The Simplehuman paper towel holder also has a heavy duty weighted base. The Simplehuman paper towel holder’s base is also non-slip. The overall design of the Simplehuman paper towel holder is also made out of brushed stainless steel. The brushed stainless steel rod features a finger loop.

Oxo Vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder: Desirable Qualities

The Oxo paper towel holder has a number of qualities that are most talked about. The tops ones are that the Oxo paper towel holder is easy to install and use. The Oxo paper towel holder has robust build material and is thus durable. You also enjoy sturdiness and maneuverability when using the Oxo paper towel holder. The Simplehuman paper towel holder ranks high on being easy to install and maneuverability. The Simplehuman paper towel holder is also notable for softness and sturdiness. The build quality of the Simplehuman paper towel holder is robust thus making it durable.

Pros Of The Oxo Paper Towel Holder

One of the good things about the Oxo paper towel holder is the paper towel edge is always accessible. It does not unravel as well which is a desirable quality. This is made possible by the internal resistance in its design. The Oxo paper towel holder’s base is non-slip and weighted; that provides effective stability. The Oxo paper towel holder can accommodate any size or brand of paper towels. The Oxo paper towel holder’s spring activated arm holds the paper towel securely.

Plus it allows you to easily tear using one hand. The Oxo paper towel holder also has a carry knob for easy movement. The Oxo paper towel holder is ready for use; there is no prior assembly required. The fact that the Oxo paper towel holder is free standing is convenient. As in, you have the flexibility of moving it around placing it exactly where you need it. The Oxo paper towel holder is quite cheap; considered a budget item.

Cons Of The Oxo Paper Towel Holder

The brushed stainless steel surfaces tend to be prone to have fingerprint marks. This may be annoying and could necessitate having to frequently wipe them off. The spring activated arm and the one hand tear functionality tend to malfunction after some time.

Pros Of The Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder

Though costing more than the Oxo paper towel holder, the Simplehuman paper towel holder is still a budget item. The Simplehuman paper towel holder’s finger loop makes it easy to pick and move it. The Simplehuman paper towel holder comes in a variety of finishes. This makes it easier to choose a design that complements your kitchen design. The Simplehuman paper towel holder has a good warranty – 5 years.

No prior assembly is needed when you get the Simplehuman paper towel holder. The Simplehuman paper towel holder can also accommodate any size or brand of paper towels. The Simplehuman paper towel holder’s variable tension arm is necessary for one hand tear. The Simplehuman paper towel holder also features an elegant design. This is due to its brushed stainless steel finish.

Cons Of The Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder

The Simplehuman paper towel holder also has that issue of fingerprint marks. Especially if it is touched or moved often, fingerprint marks will tend to smudge the surface. This is worsened especially if the color of the Simplehuman paper towel holder is white. This makes it highly susceptible to getting covered with visible dirt marks. This can be inconvenient for some people. The Simplehuman paper towel holder is also prone to malfunctions at time goes on. For instance, the one hand tear functionality can become less efficient. In some cases it may stop working at all.

Factors To Consider When Choosing Paper Towel Holders

Paper towel holders come in various different types of designs. There are also several other variables that are at play. That is why you have to consider some factors before buying a paper towel holder. First of all you have to consider where the paper towel holder will be used. Whereas it is mostly in kitchen, it may either be a domestic kitchen or a commercial one. Some paper towels are suited for either and some for both. The other factor is the mounting type which also goes along with where it will be used. Another factor is the type of paper towels the paper towel holders accommodates. For instance, most paper towel holders accommodate paper towel rolls. However, there are also some that accommodate folded paper towels. Closely tied to that will be the size of the paper towels in question. There are paper towel holders that can hold paper towels of any size or brand. It would be best to purchase such.

Then you must consider the paper towel’s features. Does the paper towel holder offer enough stability? Can you efficiently tear off the paper towel using one hand? Does the paper towel holder guard against things like ripping or clogging? These are some of the things to look for. Another important factor is the build material of the paper towel holder. There are many different types but stainless is often the best. This is because it cannot rust. This is desirable especially given that paper towel holders tend to be used close to moisture. You must also consider the extent of care and maintenance a paper towel holder requires. This has bearings on cost which also implies the price tag is another factor to consider.

Which Mounting Type Is Best For A Paper Towel Holder?

This is a question that comes down to the space dynamics in your intended location. Let us suppose you want to use your paper towel holder in a kitchen. There are certain things to consider. How much of countertop space do you have in your kitchen? If you have abundant countertop space then a free standing paper towel holder would be ideal. Then if the space in your kitchen is generally limited, especially countertop space, a wall mounting type is best. You can also find paper towel holders that are designed to be fitted under cabinets. That is also ideal when space is limited. Generally, paper towel holders can be placed on counters, walls, under or inside cabinets, or under sinks. You must also consider the quality of the paper towel holders for the different locations.

How Do You Determine The Best Paper Towels?

There are certain physical attributes that you must look out for. You have to consider the general physical strength of the paper towel. Then you must also factor in the absorbency and scrub strength. Weight is yet another consideration when choosing paper towels. The softness of the paper towels is also important. Ideally you want paper towels that are lightweight, soft but considerably strong. The other important consideration is their ability to filter water. That is in a way tied to the thickness of the paper towels. These are some of the basic considerations to help you choose the best paper towels.

Oxo Vs Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder: Our Pick

The Oxo paper towel holder and the Simplehuman paper towel holder are largely similar. This may be enough of a basis to bring down the conclusion to the price point. Yes, the Oxo paper towel holder costs less than the Simplehuman paper towel holder. However, our best pick between the two is the Simplehuman paper towel holder. It is not that costlier after all. The Simplehuman paper towel holder’s price is still a preferable budget price. Anyways, one of the reasons why the Simplehuman paper towel holder is best is its warranty. You get a 5 year warranty something that is not there for the Oxo paper towel holder. The Simplehuman paper towel holder also weighs more. This means it offers even more steadiness or stability given its weighted base. The Simplehuman paper towel holder’s finger loop streamlines handling and ease of moving it around. The Simplehuman paper towel holder comes in 3 different finishes you can choose from. This is unlike the Oxo paper towel holder with just one finish.

Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)

Which Is The Best Material For A Paper Towel Holder?

The most recommended material for a paper towel holder is stainless steel. This is largely because it is durable and also elegant looking. Paper towel holders are typically used in spaces prone to moisture. Stainless steel is best for that because it is impregnable to rust. Plus it is generally easy to clean. Other common materials are plastic, wood, and ceramic. Those materials have varying levels of dependability though they all look elegant. Wood obviously is the least ideal given its vulnerability to moisture.

How Long Do Paper Towel Holders Last?

The longevity of a paper towel holder depends on a number of things. The foremost one is the type and quality of the build material. The next thing is the design of the paper towel holder. Some designs may not be robust enough thus becoming susceptible to wear and tear. The other issue is how responsibly or not one uses the paper towel holder. If all the aforementioned aspects are in check, however, paper towel holders should last for years.

What Else Can A Paper Towel Holder Be Used For?

A paper towel holder can be creatively used for other than just holding paper towels. It can also be used to hold some domestic items that are in roll form. One of such common items is tape e.g. rolls of duct tape, painters tape, and washing tape, amongst others. Of course you will not necessarily get the same functionality such as one hand tear. However, for just basic stacking of tape for easy access or storage, a paper towel may suffice.

Conclusion

It comes down to what your core determinants are. If solely the price point is your deciding factor then the Oxo paper towel holder is for you. However, if you want to get more and added convenience, the Simplehuman paper towel holder is best. The good thing is that the Simplehuman paper towel holder costs only a few dollars. Thus the extra cost is negligible when you look at the added convenience e.g. a 5 year warranty.

Oxo Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Oxo Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder
Simplehuman Paper Towel Holder